Book a session — Calendly
Surgical acupuncture is an adjunct, not an anaesthetic. What the 1970s reports described, what trials support, and how to use needles around an operation.
Where this idea comes from
Reports of surgery performed with needles instead of drugs circulate widely, usually traced to Chinese hospitals in the 1970s. The images are striking and the story is memorable, and it has settled into a vague belief that acupuncture can substitute for anaesthesia when someone is anxious about an operation. Television reports of the period showed patients awake and talking during thyroid surgery, which reinforced the impression.
The original practice was narrower than the retelling. It required electrical stimulation, careful patient selection, premedication and a cooperative surgical team, and it was used for a small number of procedures. It was also studied as an adjunct, a word that tends to disappear when the story travels. In most of those reports, patients also received local anaesthetic or sedatives.
What Chinese medicine actually says
Chinese medicine has a long history of using needles for pain, and modern Chinese hospitals do use electroacupuncture alongside drugs for some operations. The classical texts describe needling to move qi and blood and to relieve pain; they do not describe rendering a patient unconscious for abdominal surgery. Electroacupuncture in that setting aims to reduce the amount of drug needed, which is a different claim from removing it.
Anaesthesia in the modern sense depends on monitored unconsciousness, control of the airway, muscle relaxation and the ability to reverse effects quickly. No acupuncture protocol provides those. A practitioner working within the tradition would describe needles as an addition to anaesthesia, never as its substitute.
What the research says
The strongest related evidence concerns nausea, not unconsciousness. Ezzo and colleagues, in a 2006 Cochrane review, found that stimulation of the PC6 point reduced chemotherapy-induced nausea when compared with sham, which is a specific and limited finding. It supports adjunct use, not surgical anaesthesia.
Vickers and colleagues reported modest benefits for chronic pain in 2018, again in a different context. The NCCIH notes that acupuncture has been studied for post-operative nausea and pain, usually alongside standard care. For standing in for general anaesthesia, the available sources offer no trial, so data are not available. Trials of acupuncture for post-operative pain compare it with sham or with usual care, not with general anaesthesia.
What you can realistically expect
Before an operation, Ghislaine Morin may see patients at Centre Équilibre in Grenoble for anxiety, sleep or post-operative nausea, and she will always ask whether the surgeon and the anaesthetist know. A session in Grenoble is planned around the date of surgery rather than instead of it. She will check whether you take anticoagulants, which changes how needling is approached.
The TCM dispensary at the centre can prepare a formula for anxiety or constipation after surgery, with the timing checked against your prescriptions. Expect a practitioner who writes to your anaesthetist if you ask, who respects fasting instructions, and who never suggests cancelling or reducing anaesthesia for any procedure.
When to consult, and when not to
Consult for support around surgery, and tell both your anaesthetist and your acupuncturist what the other is doing. Timing matters: some points are avoided on the day of an operation, and herbal formulas can interact with drugs, so the anaesthetist needs the list of everything you take. Bring your operation date and the anaesthetist's letter to the session.
Do not decline anaesthesia, and do not postpone an operation to try needles first. If a practitioner suggests that acupuncture can make anaesthesia unnecessary, or advises stopping prescribed medication before surgery, end the consultation and speak to your surgeon. That advice is outside any reasonable scope of practice.
Frequently asked questions
Can acupuncture be used instead of anaesthesia?
No. Acupuncture does not produce unconsciousness, protect the airway or allow a surgeon to operate safely. It has been studied as an addition for post-operative nausea and pain, always alongside standard anaesthesia. Any practitioner who offers it as a substitute makes a claim that no listed evidence supports.
Can it help before an operation?
It can help some people with pre-operative anxiety and with sleep in the days before surgery, and it is sometimes used for post-operative nausea. Tell your anaesthetist, because timing and any herbal formula matter. It works alongside the surgical plan rather than around it.
Should I stop my medication before surgery for acupuncture?
No. Decisions about stopping medication before an operation belong to your surgeon and anaesthetist, never to an acupuncturist. Write down everything you take, including herbs and supplements, and give the list to the anaesthetist at the pre-operative appointment so interactions can be checked properly.
Useful links
Sources
- Ezzo J et al., "Acupuncture-point stimulation for chemotherapy-induced nausea or vomiting", Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2006 — https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD002285.pub2
- NCCIH, "Acupuncture: what you need to know" — https://www.nccih.nih.gov/health/acupuncture-what-you-need-to-know
- Vickers AJ et al., "Acupuncture for chronic pain: update of an individual patient data meta-analysis", Journal of Pain, 2018 — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2017.11.005
- Author:Ghislaine Morin
- URL:https://accu-grenoble.com/en/article/acupuncture-replaces-anaesthesia
- Copyright:All articles in this blog, except for special statements, adopt BY-NC-SA agreement. Please indicate the source!